College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Autistic Plea Less Pity

People with autism speak out for equal treatment in society.

By GENET LAKEW

Metro Editor

Print this article

Published: Monday, November 2, 2009

Updated: Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Autism Walk

Genet Lakew

Detached from the sea of walkers at the annual Walk Now for Autism Speaks fundraiser in D.C.,  was a group of about 15 autistic individuals who stood protesting.

Against the backdrop of the Washington monument, they chanted “Autism Speaks doesn’t speak for us,” and “Autistic people speak. Are you listening?”

Ari Ne’eman, founder and president of the Autistic Self Advocacy Network (ASAN), led the protestors. Contrary to the mission of Autism Speaks, Ne’eman and members of ASAN allege that the organization is actually exploiting the autistic community instead of helping it.

“I saw that all too often, autistic people are kept out of the public policy discussion about us and decisions are put forward that don’t fit with our needs and don’t relate to what we want,” said Ne’eman, who, along with the other members of ASAN, is autistic.

On a misty Saturday morning, supporters came together on the National Mall for the Walk Now for Autism Speaks, and raised a total of $692,196, according to the walk’s website.

The largest grassroots autism walk effort in the country, this annual event takes place in several communities around the United States, as well as in the United Kingdom and Canada. 

According to an ASAN press release, 65 percent of the funds Autism Speaks raise go toward scientific research and identifying autism-causing genes. Autism Speaks only allocates 4 percent to services for individuals and families.

“My goal is to try and get some of the money that Autism Speaks raises given to other organizations [that] focus more on helping improve the quality of life [of autistic individuals] with supports to hold a job or supports to be able to live independently,” said Jonathan Gubits, ASAN member since 2007.

The vision of Autism Speaks is to increase awareness of the disorder, fund research into the cause, prevention, and treatment of autism and to advocate for autistic individuals and their families. Bob and Suzanne Wright, grandparents of an autistic grandchild, founded the organization in 2005.

But Paula Durbin-Westby, organizer of the protest and ASAN board member, does not believe Autism Speaks is upholding its promise and vision.

Founded in 2006, ASAN is a non-profit organization composed entirely of autistic people who work to accurately educate the public and create honest conversations about autism. By engaging in public policy advocacy, they hope to change public perception and combat misinformation, as stated on the ASAN Web site.

“It’s sort of a two-pronged approach. One, we want to educate some of the walkers about some of the tactics and methods of Autism Speaks because they use fear, misinformation and stigma about us to fundraise for their projects,” said Durbin-Westby. “They use this kind of stigmatizing information and you wouldn’t do that for another disability.”

She sites a recent campaign advertisement used by Autism Speaks to garner attention to the disorder. Titled “I Am Autism,” the video features an anthropomorphized “voice of autism” that poses as an intruder and threatens to divorce parents of autistic children and bankrupt families.

“I am autism…I know no color barrier, no religion, no morality, no currency,” said the low but deep voice in the video. “I work very quickly. I work faster than pediatric AIDS, cancer, and diabetes combined.”

ASAN members have a problem with such fundraising tactics because they feel the overall message is degrading and helps to instill a sense of fear and alarm in the general public about autism.

Ne’eman said the “I am Autism” video and other Autism Speaks projects send the message that people who are autistic should be pitied and are a burden to society.

“There are some real practical implications and how it hurts us when we’re trying to find jobs, when we’re trying to be included in schools, when we’re trying to be accepted by our peers, and enter relationships and friendships,” said Ne’eman.

Evelyn Ireland is a 14-year-old eighth grader who is autistic and is trying to wade through school and unkind classmates. She said her peers annoy her because they view her as being different from them.

“I just don’t tell people about my syndrome because I don’t want them treating me like [I’m a] weirdo, or a baby, or make fun of me more than they already do.”

Academically, she is “mainstream,” meaning the school has not placed her in a special program. She is able to attend the same classes and matriculate through school in the regular program with her friends.

Even at such a young age, Ireland wanted to come to the morning’s protest with her parents because she didn’t believe in or agree with the way Autism Speaks represents her and others like her.

She said she wants to be better represented and seen as an equal to everyday, “normal” people.
 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

12 comments

Harold L Doherty
Wed Nov 4 2009 15:59
My son is severely autistic. He is diagnosed with Autistic Disorder and assessed with profound developmental delays. He was diagnosed originally 11 years ago at age 2. He is not a high functioning person with Aspergers like Mr. Ne'eman. His life challenges are very different.

Since my son can not speak on these issues and does not understand them, I speak on his behalf as his father, provider and caregiver, as the person who has raised him, loved him and knows him.

Ari Ne'eman does NOT speak for my son.

Your name
Wed Nov 4 2009 15:58
My son is severely autistic. He is diagnosed with Autistic Disorder and assessed with profound developmental delays. He was diagnosed originally 11 years ago at age 2. He is not a high functioning person with Aspergers like Mr. Ne'eman. His life challenges are very different.

Since my son can not speak on these issues and does not understand them, I speak on his behalf as his father, provider and caregiver, as the person who has raised him, loved him and knows him.

Ari Ne'eman does NOT speak for my son.

Ann
Tue Nov 3 2009 09:35
Wonderful article on an under-reported situation. I think if people knew more about Autism Speaks they were not be supporting them. There are more appropriate groups to support that actually value all people.
Amber
Mon Nov 2 2009 18:09
Thank you for reporting on this. The voices of people from ASAN should be heard. 4% going to individuals and families? I don't think so. People with autism need much more support than Autism Speaks is giving.
Moi
Mon Nov 2 2009 17:11
Autism Speaks is just so out of touch with the autistic community. I don't know who they're speaking for, but it's not for any autistic people that *I* know.
Cori
Mon Nov 2 2009 15:35
I would have loved to attend this protest against Autism Speaks, but I'm in Canada at the other end of the continent and can't afford to travel to even the next closest city. I don't like Autism Speaks and what they stand for or what they're doing. There is enough ignorance in this world and we don't need any more of it. It sickens me to see all the fear mongering they do to generate income that doesn't even go towards the cause they claim to support. I have a hard enough time as is dealing with how people react to my Asperger's Syndrome and I don't need groups like this making it even harder.
Jennifer
Mon Nov 2 2009 12:54
Although I believe Autism Speaks is starting to turn a corner in becoming more sensitive to the feelings of those on the spectrum, they still have a LONG way to go with curbing their rhetoric. I was tempted to participate in the above-mentioned video, thinking it was going to shed a positive light on families. The ad they put out was totally misleading and I'm glad we chose not to contribute. Autism Speaks still doesn't speak for us.
Melanie
Mon Nov 2 2009 12:43
Thanks so much for this piece. It's refreshing to read about autistic people self-advocating, as opposed to the normal pity-laden pieces about autism "stealing" the souls of children.
Meg
Mon Nov 2 2009 12:39
Thank you for reporting on ASAN's campaign to stop exploitation, pity, and prejudice. Our society needs to fight against stigma and ignorance, NOT against the existence of autistic people and others with disabilities, who are human beings and should be respected as such.
complicitytheory
Mon Nov 2 2009 12:32
Great article. I wish I could have been at the protest, and I appreciate that you've written it up.
Jon
Mon Nov 2 2009 12:28
Fantastic piece! Kudos to the Hilltop for supporting inter-sectionality and civil rights for all people! Go ASAN and go Civil Rights!
Concerned
Mon Nov 2 2009 09:14
GREAT article!






log out